Leaseholder Action – challenging hidden commissions in buildings insurance

Velitor, with funding from Balance Legal Capital LLP, is pursuing a claim on behalf of up to 900,000 residential leaseholders in England and Wales. The claim seeks to recover secret insurance commissions concealed within buildings, terrorism and other insurance and shared between landlords and insurance brokers.

Most modern leases provide for leaseholders to cover their landlord’s cost of arranging buildings, terrorism and other insurance for the common parts. Landlords and their brokers have developed a practice of including large commissions for themselves. These commissions are concealed within the insurance premiums. In some cases, the practice goes back to 1997. Leaseholders are unaware of this practice.

Concerns over the increasing cost of insurance after the Grenfell Tower fire led the government to ask the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) to investigate. In April 2023, the FCA found that in the period 2019-22, approximately £160 million of commission was taken from leaseholders and concealed within insurance premiums collected by landlords[1]. Brokers shared £80 million of the commission with landlords and their property managing agents.

On 24 July, we launched the bookbuild for an opt-in collective action in the High Court. The claim will seek to recover these secret commissions from landlords and their insurance brokers, together with additional Insurance Premium Tax and compound interest. We hope to issue proceedings later in 2024.

For further details, or to register your interest in the case, please visit Leaseholder Action.

 


 

[1] FCA, ‘Multi-Occupancy Buildings Insurance – Broker Remuneration’ (April 2023) https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/multi-firm-reviews/multi-occupancy-buildings-insurance-broker-remuneration.pdf