Distressed debt investors – a multi-jurisdictional view on bondholder rights and remedies

Changes in macroeconomic conditions have caused a significant increase in risk amongst certain financial products, including the risk profile associated with primary and secondary corporate bond markets. As investors have targeted greater returns against historically low base rates, unregulated and niche investment opportunities have been presented as alternative forms of investment (often via intermediaries). Where there is a default (or one appears likely), it is important for bondholders to move quickly to protect their interests.

Velitor Law has acted for numerous clients, of all sizes and backgrounds, in relation to failed bond products and bondholder claims. Our work has involved acting against issuers and counterparties based all over the world. Some of these matters result from mere commercial/trading failure, others to more serious and suspected civil fraud, insolvency claims and/or professional negligence claims.

Ultimately, the outcome in respect of both can be similar – individual bondholders or investors being deprived of both their principal investment as well as any coupon or interest payments owing.

Here we consider the options open to bondholders and how taking positive early action can ensure the greatest chances of successful recovery.

We also comment on how other key jurisdictions have recently approached distressed bond situations and how a multi-jurisdictional approach is commonly becoming key to preserving value and prospects of recovery, whether via direct bondholder claims, or otherwise.

I. Contractual remedies

Very often a bondholder’s investment will be governed by at least the following documentation: (i) a subscription agreement, (ii) a deed of trust, and (iii) a deed of security. It is common for bondholders’ rights to be placed into the hands of, or overseen by, a security trustee. Generally described, a security trustee is obliged to act in the best interest of bondholders and to make decisions and take collective action, for and on their behalf, in relation to the investment.

Therefore, the first step for any bondholder who has not received an interest coupon, or who is experiencing difficulties associated with their investment, is to establish and properly understand what documents govern the investment and to establish if there is any security trustee.

This may be complicated if the investment has been made via an intermediary or agent. However, this need not be fatal as any agent or intermediary would still be required to hold the relevant information relating to that investment.

In the event of a default on the product, it is key that the security trustee is notified and that steps are taken to compel them into action. In most cases, diligent trustees will be well ahead of this. However, we have seen cases where they have not been and/or are unwilling or unable to act. Delays such as these can be fatal.

In circumstances where there is no security trustee, or where they refuse to act, it may be possible to avoid protracted trustee processes and for bondholders to act directly to enforce their rights against the issuer and/or any guarantor.

Advice should also be obtained with regard to whether there may be claims which arise in or from: mis-selling, misstatement or misrepresentation of the bond product.

II. Creditor rights and claims against third parties

In certain circumstances, bondholders and/or beneficial owners will also need to consider whether the issuer is solvent and whether or not they are better placed to pursue their interest as a creditor to the issuer.

The ability, and way, to pursue a position as a creditor will vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and may also be influenced by the contractual position. However, the pursuit of a creditor position is ordinarily via a formal insolvency process.

As a practical consideration, in the event that creditor positions are being considered there is often sense in a group of bondholders joining forces and co-ordinating amongst each other to liaise on representation, appointments of Insolvency Practitioners, and to consider other collective redress that may be available. Velitor has experience in representing such groups and in sourcing funding to enable such action to take place.

In instances of systemic bond failure, there may be claims and actions which should be considered against third parties. These third parties might include guarantors, brokers, or service providers who were involved in establishing or managing the bonds.

III. International considerations

Finally, many corporate bonds are issued by entities who are based outside of England and Wales and in other ‘offshore’ financial centres. For that reason, it is also often important to consider the interplay between other jurisdictions’ laws and insolvency processes and to have an experienced team who are capable of managing litigation across multiple jurisdictions.

For example, recent decisions from the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands[1] and the Hong Kong High Court[2] have indicated that it will be more difficult for a bondholder to adopt a creditor position when there is a trustee in place.

Other jurisdictions, such as in the British Virgin Islands[3], have adopted a more fluid approach and creditor-friendly position to the direct pursuit of creditor positions despite trustees being in place.

Commonly, in distressed bondholder situations, it is key to effectively manage and exploit any cross-border opportunities by obtaining professional advice from advisors with experience in managing multi-jurisdiction litigation and cross-border insolvencies.

At Velitor, our team have expertise and on-the-ground experience in practising and running cases in the Cayman Islands, the British Virgin Islands and Hong Kong, along with extensive experience in litigation in England and Wales.

If you require any advice in relation to a bondholder claim, or would like to discuss any issues you have in respect of an investment of this type, you should contact either Christopher Lillywhite or Jonathan Child for a confidential discussion.

 


 

[1] In the matter of Shinsun Holdings (Group) Go., Ltd, [2022] FSD 192 of 2022

[2] In the matter of Leading House Group Limited, [2023] HKCFI 1770

[3] In the matter of Haimen Zhongnan Investment Development (International) Co. Ltd, BVIHC (Com) 2022/0183)