Latest updates on the UK Arbitration Bill – key changes and progress

What is the latest update on the Arbitration Bill?

The Arbitration Bill was not passed in time for the dissolution of parliament prior to the UK’s general election. However, the new Labour government has essentially picked up the Arbitration Bill, re-introducing it in the recent King’s Speech. The Bill had its second reading in the Lords on 30 July, and mostly mirrors the previous Conservative government’s draft. The most significant change between the two documents is a clarification on investor-state arbitrations discussed further below.

The Bill will proceed to the committee stage on 11 September 2024.

The current version of the Bill can be found here,

Generally speaking, the Bill is seen as an exercise in fine-tuning, with the Arbitration Act 1996 otherwise not generally felt to have needed wholesale change. However, some key changes are included and these are discussed further below, including in essence the reversal of the recent UK Supreme Court decision on the governing law of arbitration agreements.

According to the new government, “the bill aims to modernise arbitration laws from 1996 and secure London as the global centre for arbitration, as well as ensuring decisions made by our arbitrators are enforced in other countries and are recognised by governments internationally.”

“This government is committed to securing the UK as a world leader in dispute resolution. Modernising the quarter-century old laws around arbitration will make it quicker, cheaper and more efficient for people and businesses looking to settle legal disputes.”

The Bill seeks to remove some lacunas and inefficiencies, and the fact that the now 27-year-old law is being updated may also be seen as maintaining the competitiveness of London as a seat. This is especially so given that in 2021, Singapore drew equal with London as the top venue choice for arbitrations for the first time.

Changes to the 1996 Act

An important change is a clarification of the law applicable to arbitration agreements, which according to the Bill will be the law of the seat where this is not otherwise expressly agreed by the parties. In the most significant change from the pre-election draft, the new Bill clarifies that this section on applicable law does not apply to investor-state arbitrations. It is thought that the prospect of English domestic law applying to such matters may discourage states from choosing London as a neutral venue for their investor-state arbitrations, including treaty disputes.

The Bill also codifies the power to issue the equivalent of summary judgment in arbitrations. Whilst this may currently be done, arbitrators are in practice reluctant to issue such awards (particularly when compared to English litigation), often borne of a concern to avoid challenges in court on grounds of serious irregularity.

The other proposals remain the same as the earlier bill, and are:

  • Codification of the duty of disclosure for arbitrations in relation to matters which may affect their impartiality.
  • Strengthening arbitrator immunity against liability for resignations and applications for removal.
  • Empowering emergency arbitrators to issue peremptory orders and make relevant applications for court orders.
  • Revising the framework for challenges to an arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction under section 67 of the 1996 Act, including to prevent a full rehearing before the court.

Effect of applicable law change

The Bill represents a change to the common law position on the applicable law of arbitration agreements as confirmed most recently by the Supreme Court in Kabab-Ji SAL v Kout Food Group [2021] UKSC 48.

The government’s background briefing notes to the King’s Speech state, amongst other things that the Bill “will implement the recommendations made in a 2022 Law Commission review of Arbitration Law, with the key reforms being:

– clarifying the law applicable to arbitration agreements that do not arise from investor-state agreements, providing that the law applicable will be those of the legal location chosen for arbitration unless parties expressly agree otherwise. This will ensure that, where arbitration is seated in England and Wales, or Northern Ireland, it will be fully supported by our arbitration law which is among the most supportive of arbitration globally.”

In particular, the effect of the new Bill will be to avoid some arguably unsatisfactory situations arising, such as those in Dallah Real Estate and Tourism Holding Co v Government of Pakistan [2010] UKSC 46 and Kabab-Ji, which were seated elsewhere but whose awards sought to be enforced in England.

In Kabab-Ji (in which Christopher Lillywhite, Liam Spender and Jason Rose of Velitor acted for the appellant award creditor) the UK Supreme Court refused enforcement and recognition of an arbitral award following a Paris-seated arbitration, whilst the French Cour de Cassation ultimately upheld the award. The situation in Dallah was similar.

Another case (which came just before Kabab-Ji), Enka Insaat ve Sanayi AS v OOO Insurance Company Chubb [2020] UKSC 38 resulted in similar issues. This was raised by the Law Commission in a 2023 consultation paper which contained provisional law reform proposals regarding the Act, explaining:

The decision in Enka v Chubb would result in many more arbitration agreements being governed by foreign law. This is simply because many international contracts, despite providing for an arbitration to be seated in England and Wales, have a foreign choice of law clause in the matrix contract.

In turn, this may lead to an increased need for parties to present expert evidence on how that foreign law governs the arbitration agreement, which might increase delay and costs. Also, the applicability of foreign law would also oust the law of England and Wales on a number of important topics, including: separability, arbitrability, scope and confidentiality.

That case was also criticised by Lord Hoffman who has argued that unless the agreement specifies otherwise, “the most convenient choice would normally be the law of the seat” since the arbitrators will apply the procedural laws of that jurisdiction.”

Obviously, the Bill will not change the substantive law which led to the inconsistent outcomes in these cases (in Kabab-Jiit was the different treatment of no-oral modification clauses in England and France), nor avoid all inconsistent transnational findings. Generally, though, the Bill will avoid similar issues arising in future.