Case update: Is your request for documents too broad? Clarity for liquidators following Webb v Eversholt Rail Limited [2026] EWHC 101 (Ch)

Introduction

The High Court has provided recent guidance to office-holders when considering requests under sections 235 and 236 of the Insolvency Act 1986. Eversholt is a reminder that applications under s.235 and/or s.236 need to be carefully and precisely crafted.

Originally, the joint liquidators of Eversholt Rail (365) Limited had sought orders for delivery-up of company documents under sections 235 (against an officer or former officer) and 236 (against third parties) of the Insolvency Act 1986 (“the Act”). The Insolvency and Companies Court determined that (i) the joint liquidators did not establish that the documents were ‘reasonably required’, and/or (ii) their requests were too broad. Sir Anthony Mann upheld that decision on appeal.

Sections 235 and 236 of the Act are tools often relied on by office-holders to enable them to fully investigate the business, affairs and matters leading to the insolvency or administration of a company. Section 235 creates the duty to cooperate with office-holders, who are able to obtain information from a company’s former officers and employees, whilst section 236 enables a court to order any party (including: any person whom the court thinks capable of giving information concerning the promotion, formation, business, dealings, affairs or property of the company) to provide documents that are relevant to an office-holder’s investigation and/or attend court to be examined.

Background

Eversholt Rail (365) Limited (also known as “365”) and Eversholt Rail Ltd (“ERL”) were sister companies operating under the Eversholt UK Rails Group who specialised in maintaining railway engines and carriages. A services agreement provided that ERL was to provide services to 365, the latter of which was only a holding company and special purpose vehicle. This meant that upon appointment, the joint liquidators had to contend with a company that had no employees and very little corporate documentation that would allow them to carry out their role effectively.

As a result, the joint liquidators requested documents from ERL and their solicitors but were not satisfied with the materials provided. Accordingly, they made an application for orders under section 235 and 236 against ERL and ERL’s solicitors.

The first instance Court considered the application which requested, amongst other things: “copies of all documents in its possession custody or control relating to the business, dealings or affairs of 365”.

ICC Judge Burton dismissed the application describing it as “broad” and “unjustified”. Criticism was made of what the Judge regarded as ‘blanket’ requests – specifically the requests for everything “relating to” 365’s business.

The Judge questioned the necessity of the application and noted that the joint liquidators, in the course of dealing with ERL and its solicitors, had failed to: (i) request a meeting with ERL to discuss the requests made, and/or (ii) seek to agree search terms and/or custodians which may have assisted in narrowing the searches.

The joint liquidators appealed on 10 grounds which all hinged on the main argument that where documents are held by a third party, a request for all documents is reasonable in order to “reconstitute the corporate knowledge of the company” under section 236 of the Act.

The findings on appeal

Sir Anthony Mann dismissed the appeal.

Section 235 of the Act requires office-holders to have a “reasonable requirement” for the information and documents requested. Section 236 does not expressly refer to such a requirement.

The joint liquidators argued that where they were trying to reconstitute the company’s knowledge, their request for all documents (described by the Court as an “everything forever” request) did not need to show reasonableness, and if such a requirement were to be imposed, their aim of reconstituting the company’s knowledge was in and of itself reasonable.

First, the Judge referred to the decisions in Re British & Commonwealth Holdings plc v Spicer & Oppenheim [1992], Green v BDO Stoy Hayward LLP [2005] and Re Corporate Jet Realisations Ltd [2015] as authority for the fact even though section 236 is silent to reasonableness, the reasonable requirement expressly worded in section 235 does extend to section 236 of the Act.

Second, the Judge acknowledged that the circumstances of the case were “relatively unusual”, whilst also stating that the liquidators aim of reconstituting the company’s knowledge is a legitimate purpose under the Act to bring such an application. However, it is not a good enough reason on its own to justify the wide-ranging nature of disclosure sought by the liquidators with their “everything forever” request described by the judge as being “too broad”, therefore failing to satisfy the reasonable requirement. It is clear that to bring successful section 235 and 236 applications, both the purpose and the characteristics of the application need to be clearly defined.

Sir Anthony Mann went on to note that in some circumstances an “everything forever” request may be reasonable, but that will be entirely dependent on the facts. In this case, there was cooperation from ERL and their solicitors from the outset, so such a wide-ranging request was unjustified.

Key takeaways

It is clear that the courts are willing to scrutinise the detail of section 235 and 236 applications, and office-holders will need to provide justification if they are seeking broad categories of documents over a long period of time. This is necessary in order to satisfy the ‘reasonableness’ aspect of the Act.

This case provides welcome clarification on how the Courts will approach the tests to be applied. To bring successful section 235 and 236 applications, both the purpose and the parameters of the application need to be clearly defined.

If any assistance is required in relation to matters in this case update, Velitor’s team can assist and advise. Please contact Charlotte Towerton or Jonathan Child for more information.