Summary
The Court of Appeal decision in Gibson has addressed the responsibilities of gambling operators and the procedures that should be followed where an organisation has concerns over a customer’s patterns of gambling. Gibson provides practical guidance for operators on the interpretation of the Licensing Conditions and Code of Practice which should be of some assistance to operators. In addressing the matters before it, the Court of Appeal also found that the failure of gambling operators to comply with regulatory codes of practice will not in and of itself lead to gambling contracts being invalidated.
Background
The Claimant, Mr Gibson, was a wealthy property developer who lost over £1.4m in the ten-year period between 2009 and 2019 when he was gambling on a betting exchange hosted by Betfair. Mr Gibson brought claims against Betfair for breach of its obligations under the Licence Conditions and Code of Practice (“LCCP”). The LCCP is designed, amongst other things, to ensure gambling organisations have safeguarding procedures in place to protect customers whose behaviour indicates that they may have a problem with gambling.
At first instance, evidence from two independent medical experts confirmed Mr Gibson did suffer from a gambling problem, however, His Honour Judge Bird dismissed Mr Gibson’s claim in full, finding that Betfair had appropriate systems in place and that there was no requirement to have the “most efficient system to identify problem gamblers”. In the alternative, Mr Gibson submitted that every time he placed a bet a new contract was formed, therefore renewing Betfair’s safeguarding obligations under the LCCP as an implied term in the contract. Bird J dismissed this argument finding that a contract was formed when a customer opened their account, not in every instance of a bet being placed.
Mr Gibson appealed, with the main issue for determination before the Court of Appeal being whether Betfair knew or ought to have known Mr Gibson was, in fact, a ‘problem’ gambler at any point of his ten-year gambling period with the exchange.
Findings on Appeal
The Court of Appeal found that Betfair did not know he was a ‘problem’ gambler and rejected the argument that they ought to have known. An important finding was that Betfair had made detailed and specific enquiries at the time about whether Mr Gibson could afford the losses which were being sustained, and Mr Gibson had demonstrated that he was a wealthy individual, with a large property portfolio. Mr Gibson had thus satisfied Betfair at the time that he could afford his gambling activity. As a result of the diligent enquires made by Betfair, the Court of Appeal found that there was no breach of the LCCP and that Betfair had not breached any duties to Mr Gibson.
In addition, the Court of Appeal made the following observations which may have more general application:
- it would have been very difficult to identify a ‘problem’ gambler from data analysis alone.
- Betfair’s approach to compliance evolved over time and was driven by a desire to root out ‘problem’ gamblers;
- the relevant LCCP provisions in place until 2019 were relatively undemanding; and
- Betfair had appropriate policies in place and had applied them properly.
With respect to specific arguments that had been made in relation to the Gambling Act 2005 (the “Act”), the Court of Appeal also confirmed that:
- s33 of the Act did not operate to void gambling contracts and therefore a breach of the LCCP will not render gambling contracts void;
- s24(8) of the Act provides that a failure to comply with the LCCP is not in and of itself an offence, nor does it render a party liable to a civil claim;
- any operating license is subject to the condition that the operator ensures compliance with any relevant social responsibility provision contained in a code of practice in force at the time.
Practical Considerations
Following Gibson, there are several practical issues that gambling operators may wish to consider and review as part of their standard practices and client dealings. These include:
- Reviewing internal policies that assess the customer’s affordability of the losses that may be incurred– including any due diligence and onboarding procedures.
- Reviewing internal policies regarding how ‘problem’ gamblers are identified and subsequently supported.
- Reviewing how the policies are implemented as a matter of practice, and how safeguarding procedures are handled internally.
It is also advisable for gambling operators to periodically review their policies and procedures, ensuring those reviews are well documented, together with any revisions which may be made.
The benefits of doing so were made clear in this case. Although Mr Gibson’s financial well-being and status had in fact changed over time, given the policies in place and their implementation, Betfair were held not to know this. Betfair were also not found to know that Mr Gibson was a ‘problem’ gambler. Betfair had carried out appropriate checks repeatedly over time and were given detailed information by Mr Gibson about his finances and about where the money he gambled with came from. Whilst Mr Gibson was dishonest in providing such information, Betfair were held not liable because it had done all it reasonably could. The Court also noted the practical difficulties in identifying a ‘problem’ gambler who is not being honest.
Betfair were given credit for the fact its approach to compliance: (i) evolved over time, (ii) had been well documented and recorded, and (iii) was driven by a desire to root out ‘problem’ gamblers.
If any assistance is required in relation to matters in this case update, Velitor’s team can assist and advise. Please contact Charlotte Towerton or Jonathan Child for more information.