Case update: MUR Shipping BV v RTI Ltd [2024] UKSC 18

Overview

In 2022, the Court of Appeal handed down its decision in MUR Shipping BV v RTI Ltd. You can read our earlier comment on the Court of Appeal’s decision, along with an outline of the further facts of the case here. However, in 2024 the Supreme Court allowed MUR’s appeal against the Court of Appeal’s decision, and ultimately went on to reject RTI’s claim for damages. This note is therefore a brief update on the outcome of the case.

By way of brief background, the dispute concerned a contract of affreightment between MUR Shipping (the shipowners – “MUR”) and RTI Ltd (the charterer – “RTI”) and centred on a force majeure clause defining a Force Majeure Event as one that “cannot be overcome by reasonable endeavours from the party affected”. Following RTI’s parent company being placed on the US sanctions list, RTI could no longer pay freight in USD as was required under the contract. MUR suspended performance and RTI, who offered to pay in Euros and cover any conversion costs or losses, claimed damages for chartering substitute vessels during the suspension.

In the arbitration proceedings commenced by RTI, the Tribunal decided that although sanctions caused delay in USD payments, the situation could have been overcome by MUR’s reasonable endeavours. Damages were awarded to RTI.

MUR appealed to the High Court under section 69 of the Arbitration Act. Jacobs J held that the obligation to pay in USD was fundamental, and that reasonable endeavours relate to fulfilling contractual performance, not achieving a different form of performance. The Court of Appeal, by a majority, reversed the decision of Jacobs J at first instance in RTI’s favour. MUR appealed to the Supreme Court.

Findings by the Supreme Court

MUR’s primary argument before the Supreme Court was that reasonable endeavours language in a force majeure clause did not require acceptance of non-contractual performance unless expressly agreed or provided for in the contract. RTI contended that such performance must be accepted if it causes no detriment to the party invoking the clause and achieves the same result.

The Supreme Court unanimously allowed MUR’s appeal, reversing the Court of Appeal’s decision. The fundamental principle relied upon by the Supreme Court was that freedom of contract “includes freedom not to contract; and freedom not to contract includes freedom not to accept the offer of a non-contractual performance of the contract”. Other key points noted by the Supreme Court included:

  1. Fundamental point of principle – The Court of Appeal erred in approaching the case as turning on the specific wording of the force majeure clause, rather than recognising the broader principle at stake.
  2. Causation – Force majeure clauses involve a causation inquiry. An event will not have been caused by a force majeure event if the affected party can reasonably prevent the failure of performance.
  3. Reasonable endeavours relate to contractual performance – Reasonable endeavours require steps aimed at achieving contractual performance, not adopting non-contractual alternatives. In these circumstances, paying in Euros did not amount to contractual performance from RTI. Additionally, since the banking delay for USD payments remained in place, it was not “overcome” by the offer of non-contractual performance.
  4. Clear words are required to forgo contractual rights – RTI’s obligation was to pay in USD, and MUR was entitled to insist upon this form of payment. Contractual rights are given up only through explicit waiver and/or wording.
  5. Certainty of Contract – Parties must be able to assess with “reasonable confidence” whether a force majeure clause applies. Reliance should not depend on retrospective inquiries into concepts such as “detriment” or the “underlying purpose” of the obligation.

The Court only briefly touched on the doctrine of frustration, noting that it operates by law, applies narrowly, and automatically terminates the contract. Force majeure clauses, by contrast, can cover a broad range of circumstances. Therefore, even if frustration does not arise where reasonable non-contractual performance is available, this would not prevent a party from relying on a force majeure clause in the same situation.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court approached its analysis more holistically than the Court of Appeal, allowing the clause to be relied upon to discharge MUR from its obligations from what was otherwise a valid and enforceable contract.

The decision therefore reinforces the importance of clear and specific drafting in force majeure clauses, and obtaining prompt advice both prior to entering into any agreement, and/or when disputes may arise.