Insurance law in Brazil is undergoing major reform with the entry into force of Law No. 15.040/24 (“New Brazilian Insurance Act” or “the Act”) on 11 December 2025. The Act expressly repeals the insurance provisions currently contained in the Brazilian Civil Code and introduces significant changes affecting foreign insurers and reinsurers underwriting Brazilian risks.
The Act is the product of twenty years of debate in the Brazilian legislature and represents the first instance in which primary legislation on insurance and reinsurance is contained in a separate legal instrument. It provides for a comprehensive legal framework aimed at regulating all essential aspects of insurance and reinsurance contracts. In doing so, it goes into far greater detail than the earlier framework under the Brazilian Civil Code, leaving less room for secondary legislation by the regulatory authority, Superintendência de Seguros Privados (“SUSEP”).
Nonetheless, the Act’s provisions are not always clear, and significant changes to the insurance and reinsurance framework appear to have been introduced without a full understanding of their practical implications. On 2 July 2025, SUSEP emphasised that secondary legislation will clarify and supplement the Act’s provisions but does not affect their immediate enforceability.
A key preliminary point is that the Act adopts an insured-friendly approach that does not distinguish between consumer and non-consumer insurance contracts, and the Act applies in full force even when insurers and reinsurers are underwriting large or complex risks.
Among the areas illustrating these uncertainties are: (1) the ‘tacit formation’ of insurance and reinsurance contracts; (2) the law applicable to such contracts; (3) the deadlines for completing the claims-adjustment process; and (4) dispute resolution, with particular emphasis on arbitration. These provisions are expected to influence how insurance business is conducted from the moment the Act comes into force.
1) Formation of Insurance and Reinsurance Contracts
Articles 49 and 60(1) of the Act introduce an innovation by recognising the possibility of tacit acceptance of risk by insurers and reinsurers, where they do not reject the proposal of a potential insured or reinsured within 25 or 20 days, respectively, from the date of receipt of the proposal. This represents a significant shift in Brazilian contract law, as the Act effectively allows an insurance or reinsurance contract to be formed by silence. Although the absence of consideration may be invoked to argue that no contract was formed, it may equally be argued that the insurer or reinsurer is merely entitled to deduct any unpaid premium from the indemnity payable.
The time limit set out in Article 60(1) may be extended by secondary legislation issued by SUSEP. However, the Act requires that any such extension be justified by proof of technical necessity.
Additionally, Articles 9 and 64 establish that coverage extends to the entire insured or reinsured interest unless the contract explicitly provides otherwise. With these provisions, it has been observed that the New Brazilian Insurance Act establishes all-risks coverage as the default. Every risk relating to the type of insurance or reinsurance contracted is therefore presumed to be covered unless the contract clearly and unequivocally provides otherwise.
This signals the need for a conservative approach to what constitutes a proper proposal and the information a potential insured or reinsured must provide to allow adequate risk assessment and premium calculation.
Standard forms commonly used in the Brazilian market, as well as those used by foreign insurers and reinsurers subscribing Brazilian risks, are expected to include an even greater level of detail than they currently do. Insurers and reinsurers will need to anticipate and expressly exclude every risk not intended to fall within the scope of the contract, since any risk that relates to the relevant type of insurance or reinsurance will otherwise be deemed covered.
The length and complexity of standard forms is already considered by Brazilian courts when deciding on coverage, as they are often seen as limiting the disadvantaged party’s understanding of the contract. Articles 9 and 64 may therefore affect insurance and reinsurance business in two ways: non-contentiously, insurers and reinsurers are likely to review their policies and standard forms to ensure that every relevant exclusion is drafted expressly and unequivocally; and contentiously, courts will be required to consider whether a particular risk is related to the type of insurance or reinsurance in question, with the uncertainty over what is in fact “related” to the contract inevitably giving rise to interpretative challenges.
2) Law Applicable to the Contract
Article 4(1) provides that the Act applies not only to contracts with insurers authorised to operate in Brazil. Brazilian law is also compulsorily applicable: (a) where the insured is domiciled in Brazil; or (b) where the insured assets are in Brazil, even if the insurer is located abroad.
The Act is silent on the law applicable to reinsurance contracts, which may be viewed in two ways. On the one hand, this preserves contractual freedom. On the other, the Act provides no clear guidance and contains provisions which, although primarily aimed at dispute resolution, could be interpreted as suggesting that Brazilian law is also compulsory for reinsurance contracts directly affecting insurance contracts concluded in Brazil.
3) Deadlines for Completing the Claims-Adjustment Process
Article 86 provides that insurers have a maximum of 30 days to determine whether coverage applies, starting from the date the claim and required documentation are received. This period may be suspended twice if additional documentation is requested within the initial 30 days, and a failure to decide within this timeframe is deemed to be tacit acceptance of coverage. SUSEP may extend the period up to 120 days for contracts involving complex claims assessments.
From the insured’s perspective, the Act does not establish a precise time bar for notifying the insurer of the materialisation of the risk. Under Article 126, the one-year limitation period only begins once the insured is informed of the insurer’s express and reasoned denial. The requirement for the insured to “promptly notify the claim” is vague and may place a significant burden on insurers and reinsurers, as claims could arise after considerable delay. It may be argued that unreasonable delay could lead to forfeiture of the right to claim, but this is heavily dependent on specific circumstances.
4) Dispute Resolution: Arbitration
The Act provides that arbitral proceedings must be seated in Brazil and governed by Brazilian law. This applies not only to disputes between the insured and insurer but also to relationships among insurers, reinsurers, and retrocessionaires, pursuant to Article 131, which specifies that if a dispute directly affects enforcement of insurance contracts, these parties are also subject to arbitration in Brazil.
Furthermore, Article 129 mandates the compulsory publication of disputes submitted to arbitration and the awards issued. While parties’ identities are supposedly safeguarded, no mechanism appears to prevent disclosure of other parts of the award. This may undermine a key feature of arbitration, namely the ability to keep awards confidential, and could conflict with core principles such as procedural flexibility and party autonomy.
The regulatory authority, SUSEP, will also determine the specific information to be published.
Conclusion
The New Brazilian Insurance Act adopts a prescriptive approach, prioritising consumer protection and standardisation, imposing technical constraints, and reducing negotiation flexibility. Full compliance with the Act is expected from the moment it comes into force, and its insured-friendly approach, which does not distinguish between small and large risks, along with changes to contract formation, applicable law, claims assessment, and dispute resolution, will present challenges to global insurance players underwriting complex and atypical risks.
Our team at Velitor Law will continue to monitor developments in both legislation and jurisprudence and remains at your disposal for further assistance.