On 5 December 2025 the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by Velitor’s clients in an important case on residential service charges, The case is Spender and Others v. F.I.T Nominee and F.I.T Nominee 2 Limited [2025] EWCA Civ 1578.
This is the first time the Court of Appeal has considered how the statutory test for reasonableness of residential service charges applies in relation to costs arising under long-term agreements. This type of agreement is increasingly common in residential buildings, a typical example being contracts for the installation and maintenance of communal heat and power plants.
Section 19 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 provides that a landlord may only recover residential service charges if they are reasonably incurred. The Court of Appeal decided in Waaler v. London Borough of Hounslow [2017] 1 WLR 2817 that this means that a landlord must satisfy a two-limb test. The first being a rational decision-making process. The second that the decision represents an objectively reasonable outcome. Waaler emphasises the importance of the outcome being objectively reasonable. Waaler also explains that if both limbs of the section 19 test are not met then the service charge is capped at the amount the court or tribunal considers objectively reasonable.
The argument in this case focusses on how section 19 test applies where the landlord is demanding service charges flowing from costs arising under a long-term agreement with a third party supplier. The contracts in this case are for rented intercom, door entry, car park gates and barriers and television distribution systems. The contracts were entered into by the original developer for 20 year terms with RPI linked price increases, continuing year-to-year if they were not terminated. The challenge related to 2018-20. It was common ground that the costs of these rented systems in 2018-20 amounted to about 1½ times the cost of buying and installing new systems. The landlord said it had no choice but to continue the rental arrangements. Our clients challenged the costs as not being reasonably incurred.
Our clients represented themselves before the First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal. In 2023 our clients won a reduction of 81% in the First-tier Tribunal. In 2024 the landlords appealed to the Upper Tribunal and it reversed that decision. The Upper Tribunal substituted a reduction of 25% for 2020 only.
The Upper Tribunal decided that where there is a long-term agreement then it is for the leaseholders to demonstrate a prima facie case that there is something wrong with the charges at the time the long-term agreement is created. A prima facie case is a serious question for the landlord to answer. The Upper Tribunal held that because the leaseholders had not made any case about the position in 2000, when the contracts began, then their claim failed, save in respect of the 25% reduction for 2020 conceded by the landlords.
The Court of Appeal sets aside the Upper Tribunal’s decision. It agrees with the Upper Tribunal’s legal test but finds that it was applied incorrectly on the facts of this case. The Court of Appeal also summarises and restates how the burden of proof applies in section 19 cases, whether in the courts or the tribunal system.
The Court of Appeal – as did the Upper Tribunal before it – rejects the landlords’ argument that the mere existence of a long-term contract is sufficient to demonstrate the costs are reasonably incurred in every case. If that argument had prevailed then residential leaseholders would have been limited to challenges about the quality of goods or services provided under any contract, whether long-term or not. The Court of Appeal finds this would have rendered the statutory protection of section 19 useless.
As to the legal and evidential burden in section 19 cases, the Court of Appeal also explains that where a challenge is made to a cost arising under a long-term agreement then the legal and evidential burden is on the leaseholder to raise a prima facie case. One way that can be done is by pointing to the prices being so far out of line with market norms in 2018-20 that there must have been something wrong with the price agreed at the start of the contract. If there is no evidence of fact available about the circumstances in which the contract was created then it may mean expert evidence is required as to options open to the decision-maker at the time the contract was made.
Importantly, if the leaseholders raise a prima facie case that there is something wrong with the contract at the outset, then the evidential burden of proof will be on the landlord. The landlord will have to show that the costs are reasonably incurred. The landlord will still bear this evidential burden even where a developer novates a contract to a landlord. If the landlord fails to discharge the evidential burden then the court or tribunal is likely to find in favour of the leaseholder challenging the cost.
Liam Spender, Head of Real Estate Litigation at Velitor Law, says:
“The decision is welcome news to leaseholders dealing with service charges arising under long-term agreements. It clarifies that they have protection in relation to both the amount charged and the quality of goods and services provided. This judgment also clarifies the limits of the Upper Tribunal to decide matters without hearing evidence itself. The judgment is also important in saying that landlords cannot hide behind the terms of their contracts, or point to missing documents and say that the leaseholders have not raised a case for them to answer.”
The case will now be returned to the First-tier Tribunal to determine the question of whether the charges are reasonably incurred in accordance with the legal test as explained by the Court of Appeal.
There are other noteworthy features of this case:
1) This is a rare example of proceedings being remitted from the Court of Appeal back to the First-tier Tribunal. In this case the Court of Appeal was not persuaded that the Upper Tribunal had made a fair decision having adopted a different legal test to that advocated by both parties. The Upper Tribunal is criticised for finding that the tenants had not raised a case for the landlords to answer when they were given no opportunity to address a different legal test.
2) The Court of Appeal’s judgment suggests that it is good practice for a landlord entering into any form of long-term agreement to ensure that there is an effective break clause. Particularly where prices are likely to fall as technology develops. In this case there was a break clause but it was only exercisable at years 7 and 14 of a 20 year term and on payment of 4 times the annual rent, roughly £800,000.
3) The landlords had no copies of the relevant contracts in their own names, or in the name of their immediate predecessor in title. They could also only produce 2 of the 5 original contracts with the developer. Despite asserting that the amounts charged were reasonable, neither the landlords nor their supplier could explain the basis for the charges, or how much was for rental and how much was for maintenance. Perhaps another lesson is that landlords and managing agents must obtain and keep proper records for the full term of any long-term agreement, including contracts originally entered into by the developer.
4) The costs of the rented systems in this case were £590,000 in the period 2018-20 of which £480,000 related to the intercom and door entry systems. Collectively leaseholders at the site have paid many millions for all of these systems since July 2000 despite never gaining ownership of them.
5) It was common ground that the costs of the door entry systems in 2018-20 were about 1½ times the cost of buying and installing a new system. Nevertheless the landlords decided to continue with the same supplier with a discount of 50% from 2022. In the four years since then leaseholders have again paid costs equivalent to buying and installing a new system.
The Velitor team also included Christopher Lillywhite, Charlyn Cruz, Siavash Abbasi and Kaiz Suleman. Philip Rainey KC of Tanfield Chambers appeared in the Court of Appeal.
Velitor, with support from Balance Legal Capital, is currently pursuing a case on behalf of thousands of leaseholders against landlords for secret insurance commissions. You can find more details of the case at https://www.leaseholderaction.com