In a world where misinformation spreads so quickly, how does a person stop smear campaigns against them from happening? What can they do to salvage their reputation? This article explains what smear campaigns are and the legal remedies available to their victims.
What is a smear campaign?
Simply put, a smear campaign is a deliberate effort by a group of people to tarnish someone’s reputation. It is done by spreading negative propaganda about the victim and/or their business. A smear campaign seeks to permanently damage someone’s reputation through misinformation, whilst a trolling campaign is more focused on provoking reactions and causing short-term disruption, often for entertainment or attention.
Today, a smear or trolling attack is most commonly made online, often through social media platforms such as “X” (formerly Twitter) or Reddit. This is because misinformation and offensive posts can spread much faster and reach a wider audience online/ via social media.
On social media platforms, attackers can also employ the use of bots – a software application that runs automated tasks on the Internet – to coordinate and push smear or trolling campaigns. This has the effect of multiplying the posts and reposts, and by extension the reaction of the smear campaign, particularly where it is well-funded.
Who can be the victim of a smear campaign?
Individuals, private businesses and NGOs can all fall victim to smear campaigns. They have frequently been used to target politicians or public figures, activists and journalists. They can also be used by competing businesses. For example, in AL-KO Kober Ltd and Mr Paul Jones v Mr Balvinder Sambhi (t/a Torquebars) [2017] EWHC 2474 (QB), the defendant was developing his own rival product and posted videos on his Youtube channel with false accusations against the claimant and his business. Specifically, the videos implied that the claimant’s product (an automotive tool used for towing caravans) was faulty and would cause accidents. The court recognised that the defendant was embarking on an online personal smear campaign and gave judgment for the claimant.
The consequences of a smear and trolling campaign can be devastating to the victim. In addition to financial damage, they can cause irreparable distress and psychological trauma, especially when the attack is seen by friends, coworkers and the general public. It is therefore important to act promptly when this happens.
What immediate steps to take when faced with a smear campaign?
When faced with a smear campaign, we would advise victims to consider:
- Responding, if appropriate, factually and succinctly;
- Managing their online reputation promptly, for example, by issuing cease and desist letters or requesting the social media platforms to delete the offensive posts via their own takedown mechanisms;
- Considering legal action; and/or
- In some instances, let the comments ‘die’, especially when there is little to no audience, as sometimes it may better to not draw more attention to it.
What kind of legal redress is available?
The most common legal options include:
- Defamation. A meritorious defamation claim may lead to the attacker(s) retracting the offensive material, publishing an apology, making a statement in open court and/or making an offer otherwise to make amends. The most common defences raised in these situations are the defence of truth or Article 10 of the Human Rights Act 1998 (freedom of expression).
- Malicious falsehood. This redress is available when the attacks are aimed at a business. The claimant must show, amongst others, either that they suffered ‘special damage’ (i.e. loss which can be quantified in monetary terms) or that the words upon which the action was founded were calculated to cause pecuniary damage.
- Data protection. Section 10 of the Data Protection Act 1998 (“DPA 1998”) allows an individual to require a data controller to cease processing their personal data. This is helpful where the data subject’s personal data – for example name, photograph, address – is disseminated all over the smear campaign. There are, however, a few exceptions to Section 10 of the DPA 1998, including the processing of ‘journalistic, literary or artistic material’. In the case of AL-KO, the Court allowed the claimant’s data protection complaint and ordered the defendant to stop processing the claimant’s data.
- Criminal. There may also be a criminal element in smear campaigns, for example via online violence or harassment. In February 2025, Mr Raymond Birnie (75) was sentenced by Judge Mark Bishop at the Crown Court in the Huntingdon Law Courts for nine years and three months for multiple offences, including launching a smear campaign against his stepsister during a bitter inheritance battle (Case reference: 37CJ1420422 / 37CJ1174322). Mr Birnie had, out of spite, distributed leaflets accusing his stepsister and her husband of grooming children online (an allegation that was found to be false).
- Complaints to media regulators. Individuals or companies who have been attacked in the media may obtain vindication relatively cheaply by lodging a complaint to the appropriate regulator, for example to the Information Commissioner’s Office (“ICO”). If found at fault, the ICO may issue enforcement notices and/or monetary penalties, up to a maximum of £17 million in the most serious cases.
If you or your business are facing a smear campaign, including online trolling, our media and reputation management team at Velitor has the expertise to act swiftly and strategically, guiding you towards the most effective legal recourse.