Case update: Crypto assets and the limits of conversion – Ping Fai Yuen v Fun Yung Li & Anor [2026] EWHC 532 (KB)

Summary

The Claimant owned c.2,300 Bitcoin (valued between £160 million and £180 million) (“the Bitcoin”). The Claimant alleged that whilst divorce was in contemplation, his estranged wife (the First Defendant), assisted by her sister (the Second Defendant), stole the Bitcoin. Although the Bitcoin was held in a “cold wallet”, the Defendants were able to access and replicate its contents by covertly recording the Claimant in order to find out the “seed phrase”[1]. The Defendants then dispersed the Bitcoin to 71 different wallets.

Amongst other causes of action, the Claimant’s claim centred on the tort of conversion and trespass to goods. The Claimant argued that by recording his password and dispersing the Bitcoin, the Defendants intentionally interfered with his personal property and effectively deprived him of its use. The Defendants applied to strike out this aspect of the Claimant’s claim. The Defendants submitted that these causes of action had no real prospect of success because Bitcoin is an intangible asset, to which these torts cannot apply. The Court agreed and confirmed the tort of conversion cannot apply to crypto or digital assets.

The legal status of crypto assets in English Law

Typically, the law categorises assets as either choses in possession (tangible) or choses in action (intangible). This distinction is important as the type of asset determines the cause of action a claimant can bring. As per the House of Lords in the case of OBG v Allan [2008] 1 AC 1 (“OBG”), tort of conversion claims can only be brought in respect of tangible assets (i.e. choses in possession).

As a matter of legal analysis, Bitcoin (and crypto assets more generally) have existed in a state of limbo as a so-called ‘third’ category of property – i.e. neither tangible, nor intangible. Until recently, English courts have, broadly, applied a rigid approach when attaching rights to digital assets, although as argued by the Claimant’s counsel in Ping Fai Yuen the current position is in a state of flux.

In 2023, a report by the Law Commission titled ‘Digital assets’[2] (“the Report”) recommended statutory reform to recognise a third type of property for digital assets, with corresponding property rights. The Report concluded that (in light of the ruling in OBG) the new “third category” would be incapable of being ‘converted’ under the existing law. However, it recommended that courts develop specific and discrete principles applicable to “third category” assets[3]. This was recommended to allow the courts to respond to real-world facts and the specifics of each case.

The Property (Digital Assets etc) 2025 Act (“the Act”) implemented the Law Commission’s recommendations and recognised digital assets as a “third category” of personal property. Judges have since been tasked with the incremental development of the principles applying to this new category of assets.

Judgment and analysis of Ping Fai Yuen

Against this backdrop, in the recent case of Ping Fai Yuen, Mr Justice Cotter was asked to consider whether the tort of conversion could apply to digital assets.

Broadly summarised, the tort of conversion occurs when a person without authority or permission takes the property of another, or where that person deprives another of possession of their property, and thus interfering with the owner’s rights. Ordinarily a claim in conversion seeks either: (a) compensation for the value of the property, and/or (b) the return of the property. Given these requirements, the English Courts have always limited cases in the tort of conversion to ‘choses in possession’ (i.e. tangible assets).

If established, conversion is a ‘strict liability’ tort, meaning that the wrongdoer’s knowledge is immaterial.

In Ping Fai Yuen, Cotter J struck out the Claimant’s claim for the tort of conversion. While the Act allowed the common law to develop a new framework of rights, Cotter J observed that “after a comprehensive analysis of the rights and remedies in respect of “third” category property the Commission did not recommend extending the law of conversion or by enactment reversing OBG” [71].

Accordingly, Cotter J concluded that OBG “is a clear block to the extension of the law of conversion” [66]. Its “ratio is crystal clear” [78] and could not be ignored in the present case.

The claim for conversion was struck-out, whilst the claims in trespass to goods and unjust enrichment were allowed to continue (subject to further amendments being made).

Conclusion

Following Ping Fai Yuen, owners of digital assets are unable to arm themselves with the same arsenal of claims as owners of tangible assets.

Although the Claimant was able to continue its claim for unjust enrichment and trespass, the tort of conversion would have been more attractive as it is a strict liability tort. If successful, the Claimant would have been awarded damages by reference to the value of the Bitcoin at the date of conversion (particularly attractive due to the fluctuating nature of crypto assets).

Until the law changes, it would be advisable for claims dealing with misappropriated digital assets to be formulated with equitable tracing and proprietary restitution in mind, alongside consideration of urgent interim relief which might assist in ‘holding the ring’.

If you require advice in relation to the matters discussed in this case update, or broader crypto and digital asset disputes, please contact the team.

Key contacts: Christopher Lillywhite | Jonathan Child | Jason Rose | Jack Reynolds | Kaiz Suleman

 


 

[1] A cold wallet stores the private keys of the cryptocurrency entirely offline. This provides greater security by protecting the crypto assets from internet-based hacks. The password is known as the seed phrase which is a randomly generated set of 24 words.

[2] https://lawcom.gov.uk/project/digital-assets/

[3] See paragraphs 9.76 – 9.83 of the Report.